The Book Nook

Dramatic Multiple-Suspect Mystery   Ruth Ware is an author capable of serving up captivating crime thrillers time after time, and “The It Girl” is her latest novel.  In the opening pages we learn there’s been a death and that the victim is college student April Clarke-Cliveden.  Details are revealed slowly by Hannah Jones, the novel’s protagonist and the woman who discovered April’s body. The traumatic event caused Hannah’s mind to go blank, and neither police questioning nor searching her memory for more information was effective.  What she could recall was enough to give police a viable suspect who was convicted in spite of his protests of innocence. The horror and media fury surrounding April’s death effectively derailed Hannah’s life, leaving her in an emotional fog for years.  The inability to remember details has haunted her ever since, and she wonders if her testimony led to the conviction of the wrong person.  Some say the dark event keeps her tethered to the past, urging her to forget the whole ordeal.  She finally feels ready to do so when an unexpected event raises a new flurry of communications from reporters eager for her comments.  It’s also increasing her stress levels at a time when she needs it the least.   Hannah yearns to know what really happened, but revisiting details only brings more questions and widens the list of possible culprits.  Is that why some are encouraging her to give up her search?  Does it stem from concern for her or are they hiding something?  Weighing the burning need to know against the advantages of giving up forces her to decide what she’s willing to risk to find the truth. Many people who experience traumatic events say it divides their life into two segments – before and after.  The author draws on this, alternating chapters between then and now until we have a clearer picture of the events leading up to and following April’s death.   Once all the background is in place the novel races to a terrifying end. Before the tragedy, the plot focuses on a small group of people who meet at college.  At their center is April – the girl who seems to have everything, earning her the nickname “The It Girl”.  Drilling beneath the façade reveals someone who wasn’t as perfect as she seemed. The aftermath follows Hannah’s renewed interest in being certain.  Doing so causes anguish as reporters attempt to engage her in a relentless pursuit.  She also senses barriers being raised between her and the people who want her to move on. The only negative comments I heard were that some felt Hannah’s character was bland at times.  To her credit, she’s willing to follow her convictions in spite of the advantages of letting it go.  The other characters are quite interesting, causing a few readers to suggest the story should have included their viewpoints as well.  There is also strong language, so fair warning to those who dislike more than occasional use of it. That aside, this cleverly plotted domestic suspense shines at holding reader’s interest.  There’s strong character development all around and Ware fans will recognize her trademark use of providing several culprits to consider as they sift through clues.  One of the novel’s strong points is the sustained credibility of several suspects throughout the narrative. Another is the effective handling of trauma’s long-term effects by providing access to the protagonist’s thoughts.  As Hannah’s guilt ramps up, readers understand how the initial shock and ensuing emotional turmoil affect her.  While Hannah can’t always articulate why she feels certain things, she follows her instincts. The author summons her skills to give us a solid mystery with a claustrophobic feel.  She’s known for her ability to create suspense, and fans won’t be disappointed here.   There’s superb use of the interchanging timelines to create uncertainty about the convicted man’s innocence which sparks ever-increasing doubt about others’ culpability.  The dramatic conclusion may not ring true for everyone but will likely spark lively debates in book club circles.  Avoiding her usual use of more exotic locales, she picked Oxford University in England and Edinburgh, Scotland as the settings, and I liked her selection of a bookstore which served as Hannah’s refuge. Ware says her work is subconsciously influenced by Agatha Christie and other mystery writers of that era.  Her early thrillers were patterned after the “closed room” formula in which characters are put in an isolated setting or otherwise thwarted from fleeing a dangerous environment. Some feel this thriller isn’t as suspenseful as previous works but acknowledged there’s a deeper look at surviving trauma than she’s provided in earlier novels.  Compulsive readers may be tempted to finish in one sitting, and the short chapters make it easy to pick up and set down.  The overall effect is a satisfying and compelling novel.  Determining the killer will provide fun for mystery lovers, particularly those who like several likely suspects.