Around the Block

The Library   This is a rough draft of a column I wanted to write on my love of libraries, how wonderful they are, and just how vital they are to the community. But in setting out to write this column I found I couldn’t finish it—or rather, put it in a nice box with a bow on top—and I’m left with what you’re reading here. The simple fact is that libraries are both wonderful and scary places, they both build up our society and can tear it down, and it’s not just a love of libraries I want to communicate: it’s a recognition of our need for them. The column was based around a story, an experience I once had when I was just five or six years old, in my local library. I was an early and precocious reader as a child. There was nothing specific that led to this: my mom didn’t intentionally introduce books at an early age. I just took to books, and I remember preferring adult non-fiction to children’s books. I didn’t want stories about being an astronaut, I wanted the technical details of the rockets taking them into space. I had taken to checking out and renewing a book on human anatomy. I can’t say anatomy is or ever was an interest of mine. What made this book different was that instead of drawings, it was full-page color photos of dissected cadavers. I found it fascinating! One day, as I was checking out my definitely adult non-fiction book as a kid and the librarian pulled my mom aside for a brief conversation out of my earshot. It turns out the librarian was just checking in with my mom, making sure it was okay that I was checking out that book. My mom assured her it was. This was a pleasant exchange, not a charged one. It was one mom checking in with another mom. I’m sure they smiled at each other about the book, because it is somehow both a decidedly weird and yet appropriate book for a six-year-old. That was the meat of my column, the nugget that I’d expand upon and weave into 750 words or so. But I kept thinking about that experience - now over 40 years ago - and knowing it’s no longer the same. And I didn’t know what to do with that. So, writer’s block. Fast forward a few weeks and I’ve started thinking about the column, trying to compose piece of it in my head as I sometimes do. But I don’t know where it goes, or how to tie it up, and I really don’t know how to avoid the very obvious cultural flash point my line of thinking is heading towards. The truth of the matter is that books are dangerous.  There are age-inappropriate books (although deciding when a book is appropriate by age is thickheaded). There are books some kids shouldn’t see. I don’t need to be a parent to know that the principled and sky-high ideal of truly free access to literature at any and all ages is absurd. Childhood is a time when things are hidden from us and (hopefully) revealed in their due time. What to make of my story, then, and libraries, and this neat little box in words I’m trying to create? Libraries are not something in the abstract. They are not like some philosopher’s polished stone worn down by years of crafting. They are nothing like the statutes that govern and give birth to them.  Libraries are a community. They are a living, breathing organism made up of the people and families that use them. My childhood memory was a perfect example of a true library: there was the book, the checkout, but there was that other element - the librarian speaking to my mom - that brought in the community. It was that exchange between two people that makes libraries so unique. Books have always been dangerous, and always will be. It’s funny to me that people think the books have gotten more dangerous in recent years. There is far more than enough rape, genocide, murder, and torture in the classics; you can find such things anywhere in even the most restrictive library. That’s the wonder of literature: it contains everything. The fact of the matter is that our society has changed so much in recent years. Our society is both more open to ideas and more closed off from them than it has ever been before. Books just present themselves as they are; a witness telling a story. We give those stories life. And we argue about them. Those stories live in the community of the library—as recommendations, as book displays, as popular items. Ultimately our society decides what is good and what is appropriate through that inevitable and indefinable process of public consumption. “Community standards” are just that; they are not mandates handed down from legislature, or somehow defined by the courts. A community knows what is good for its members. In the end it appears that is the bow on my decidedly ungainly box of a story. I can’t tie this up perfectly, and it’s not quite finished, yet it seems I’ve told the story I wanted to tell. It’s like this because libraries are exactly the same: they are places that provide answers and ask questions and leave you wanting more. Libraries are “messy,” conceptually, because they’re composed of real people (and a bunch of them at that) and those people’s feelings and beliefs. They’re so far from being simple they’re impossibly complex. So much lurks there. But they are also my favorite places.