From the Mazomanie Historical Society

James Carlisle of the Mazomanie Carlisle House   By Frank Wolf   James F. Carlisle Sr. kept the Carlisle House hotel in Mazomanie from 1868 to 1883, when he sold it to his son James F. Carlisle Jr. His son operated the hotel eight years. The two and a half story brick, well-furnished hotel was located at the corner of Brodhead and American Legion Streets (34 Brodhead Street). It was valued at $1,500 in 1869. The hotel was initially built in 1855, improved by Carlisle in 1868 and burned out in 1891. The burned hotel was immediately rebuilt by Albert Lamboley and exists today. James was born during 1820 in Vermont. He married Irish born Leah Gamble about 1843, when she was sixteen. Leah had immigrated to America when she was either eight or thirteen. The young family is found at the 1850 US Census in Otto Township of Cattaraugus County in far western New York State. James is a landlord operating a hotel there. Listing is James 26, Leah 24, Ann F. 4, Matilda 2 and Mary eight months old. The parents are listed as born in Ireland and the children in New York. In 1854 they moved to Wisconsin and settled in the Black Earth Creek Valley near Black Earth. They are listed there at the 1855 Wisconsin Census and at the 1860 US Census. The 1860 Census has him farming on $2,500 of real estate with $480 of personal estate. Listing is James 38, Leah 36, Mathilda 12, Mary 10, James F. 8, Ann J. 6, William 3 and baby Emma F. six months old. The three youngest children were born in Wisconsin. The five oldest attend school. Moving to Mazomanie in 1869, the family is settled there at the 1870 US Census, where he is a hotel keeper. No real estate or personal property values are given. The listing is James 50, Leah 46, Mary E. 25, James F. 19, Jane 16, William G. 13, Emma F. 10 and John four years old. The 1880 US Census registers James Carlisle in Mazomanie keeping a hotel – The Carlisle House. Listing is James 58, Leah 52 keeping house, James 26 keeping a livery, Jane at home 24, Emma B. 20 at home and Johnny 14 at school. Granddaughter Maud Scripture 7 also lives there along with three boarders and two servants. James Sr. died very suddenly in Mazomanie of a complication of diseases of the heart and brain on April 23, 1884. He was buried in the Mazomanie Cemetery.  The widow moved to East Orange, New Jersey by the 1895 New Jersey Census, where she is found living with her married daughter Emma Hill. The 1900 US Census finds the widow still living with her daughter in East Orange. She is 76 with nine children of whom six are then living. She continues to live with her daughter’s family at the 1910 US Census. She is now 83 with nine children of whom seven are then living. Leah died December 30, 1914 in East Orange, NJ. Son James F. Carlisle Jr. (1853-1918) married Welch born Mary Jones (1861-1931). He operated the Carlisle House until about 1890 when he moved to Chicago as a railroad civil engineer. James Jr. also operated a Mazomanie stable with the hotel. Daughter Emma B. Carlisle (1860-1925) married local boy, printer’s devil John A. Hill (1858-1916). He was a mechanical engineer working in Pueblo, CO, where he founded a newspaper and was submitting articles to national trade journals. After he became editor of several national trade magazines, they moved to New Jersey, where he founded the Hill Publishing Company in 1902. His company specialized in technical and academic books. The company merged with his friend’s McGraw Publishing Company in 1909 to form current publishing giant: The McGraw-Hill Book Company.