Around the Block
The Panopticon
The Panopticon was a disciplinary concept from the 18th century, an idea about how to design the perfect prison. It was very simple: a single tower with guards lies at the center, and around that tower are the cells, in a circle. This allows a single guard—theoretically—to observe all the prison cells at once. And it compels each prisoner to think they are being watched at all times. Further improvements included the installation of windows in each cell behind the prisoner—so shadows can be watched realistically at all times - as well mirrored glass on the guard’s tower.
I recall the Panopticon because there is a philosophy book that discusses it at length, a tidy little book called “Discipline and Punishment” by Michel Foucault, and I read that book sometime in my undergrad years. The Panopticon had a crushing effect on me, mentally, because I couldn’t get away from the fact that we are all—conceptually—trapped in a Panopticon our entire lives. We can’t get away from the gaze of other people, from all around us, spying in our little cells.
And this is the philosophical concept of the Other.
We are always being watched, more or less, whether we are out doing errands or around the house with the family or walking the dog. There is always another (an other) watching us—in theory, conceptually, if not actually. We live our lives acting out across a stage with an audience. That is part of the human condition: to be observed by the other.
Daily, I encounter The Other. This ancient philosophical concept rears its ugly head with me without fault every day. And this battle with The Other has been going on for nearly three years, most of which I’ve been blissfully unaware of it. I’ve been battling the demon of The Other on a daily basis for years, and had no idea. I’m such a failed philosopher.
You see, I pace. Or rather, in order to write, I need to pace somewhere. Next to the computer, in the room, down the hallway—it doesn’t matter where. My writing process involves regular breaks where I simply pace and occasionally gesticulate to myself while the words line up in my head. I am a very fast writer—the words just come out at a rapid staccato pace and my fingers fly over the keyboard to keep up. But then, suddenly, a screeching halt, and I realize I need a break to pace. The words have come too fast, too rapidly, and they’re jumbling on the page. If I concentrate, I can keep a rough structure, but I need to reconstruct the narrative while walking. It’s always walking.
When I was a smoker my pacing breaks naturally overlapped with smoke breaks. I was actually taking a lot more smoke breaks—as I was a pack-a-day smoker for my whole life—but they would line up, and I would get to swagger and pace and smoke at the same time.
But quitting smoking three months ago endangered all that. Suddenly I had no reason to go pace outside. I was cooped up inside my apartment clawing at the windows as people casually walked outside. I had no raison d’être to write. It was the worst writer’s block I had ever faced, and it went on for weeks. What writing did dribble out was ill-formed and misshapen.
One day it occurred to me that I was perfectly free to go outside and do nothing—and just pace. I didn’t need a cigarette or an excuse. I could, quite literally, just go pace outside sans cigarette. But that’s where The Other crept in.
You see, the place where I smoked my cigarettes, in a very small town around here, put me in a very visible spot. I was literally standing aside the biggest downtown corner building, high on a hill, visible to businesses and mostly everyone driving down the street. When I was smoking my cigarettes I didn’t mind being so visible to people living and working and driving downtown because I was doing something. I thought that the sight of a smoking, pacing man was probably within the realm of normal for most people.
But what about a pacing man alone?
That’s when I felt like everyone was looking at me. And I felt trapped in my own Panopticon, victim of the gaze of The Other.
Perhaps owing to my own diagnosed mental illnesses, I tend to go out of my way to make sure the general public does not think I am genuinely “crazy.” I think this is a good practice for those of us who live on the threshold of what it is to be a public figure. You don’t want your news coming from someone who is nuts.
Therefore I was aghast at pacing on my own outside—no cigarette, no phone, no prop—just me alone charging back and forth and gesticulating and mumbling to myself. I’d surely look like a madman and the rumors would immediately start. Friends would start “reaching out” and work emails would get a lot friendlier. Finally, a call from the boss about “increasingly bizarre public behavior.” It was all bad news.
Not to mention The Other. When we are observed—intrusively—by someone else, we frequently start doing something to allay our discomfort. “Look busy,” is a near-universal statement meaning, in its own peculiar shorthand, “doing something will make us less suspicious.” I would be facing the Gaze of The Other without the protection of an activity.
If I’m pacing and smoking I’m just an intense, pacing, smoking, guy. But without that cigarette, I’m a weird guy walking in circles.
There was, and still isn’t, a simple solution.
I go outside and pace on my own, now, every couple of hours, and for the most part I’m not self-conscious. Somehow having the swagger of a can of Red Bull makes it all easier, as if the can is an activity itself. At least once a day I startle myself and realize a good 15 or so people could conceptually see me where I’m standing, yet I can’t see them because of glass and reflections—and that scares me. The Panopticon is every present in my daily life.
But I’ve learned to live with and love The Other, and just continue my pacing, wherever it leads me.


