Geiger Counter
Zombies
Is a gorilla who knows sign language a person?
Is a synthetic life form with complex and deep ideas about right and wrong a person?
Is a human being in a permanent vegetative state a person?
I loved debating “personhood” in college. As with all the issues, I didn’t personally know the answer, but it was so fun to hear intelligent people think richly and malleably, their ideas changing and evolving as they encountered the various pressures exerted by other arguments, in a journey we always hope is toward the destination of truth. We all know what a human being is, no one ever claims their dog or cat is their favorite human. That’s a scientific term with a tidy meaning. But personhood is much trickier to pin down. The word, like all good things, has some mystery to it.
I hadn’t thought about this for 20 years, but it came up at our house last night.
“My homework says I have to read out loud to a person for 20 minutes,” said Hadley, who is in third grade.
“Read to Amanda,” I suggested.
“Dad, Amanda’s not a person,” said Hadley. “She’s a gecko.”
She had a point. Amanda exists, and does almost nothing else, in a terrarium in Hadley’s room. She has shown none of the signs or symptoms of personhood.
“Okay, read to Frida, then,” I said.
“Dad, Frida is a dog,” she replied. “She’s not a person either.”
“Personhood is difficult to define,” I told her. “I’ll bet she counts for your homework.”
Don’t get me wrong. We love reading with our daughter. We love reading to her, and we love when she reads to us. But I was in the middle of something really important, and by that, I mean I was watching a TV show about zombies.
Are zombies people? I don’t know.
“Personhood” usually describes an individual being who has moral agency. A person’s behavior can be moral or immoral, ethical or unethical, right or wrong. A person’s actions are worthy of praise or blame. They can be a hero or a villain. Aristotle pointed out that the most fundamental aspect of personhood is being able to deliberate, being able to think about the world and make choices that you rationally believe will have a good or bad impact on the people and environments around you. Social or political groups cannot do this. You cannot be good or bad based on your political party or ethnicity or faith. Those are things you are part of, but they are not people, and they are not you. You can only be a good person as an individual who thinks rationally about whether or not your actions are good or bad.
I guess that’s why it’s generally considered morally okay to shoot zombies. Because in every zombie story, they look like people, but they only act as a group, seemingly having lost their ability to make rational, individual decisions about right and wrong. Like hardcore Democrats and Republicans, they have lost the key thing that makes them special; they have abandoned the ability to make rational, individual decisions. They think and behave as a group. They are told what to think based on their tribe, not based on what is good or bad in each situation. They move in blind, staggering hordes.
I feel like I say, “I don’t know” too often when my daughter comes to me with questions about the world. But honestly, I don’t know much, because it takes a long time, a lot of reading and a ton of first-hand experience, to get to know anything. I don’t know things that I’ve heard news pundits and politicians say. Those are not things I know; they are just things I’ve heard. They may contain some facts, but facts don’t tell us all we need to know to find truth, which is far more valuable, and far more difficult to reach, than mere facts. I don’t know much.
One of the few things I do know is that I am incredibly lucky, as are all the people who waste their lives complaining, both in person and on social media, about the fact that their lives are not satisfactory. I have a wide and interesting assortment of problems, just like everyone else, but here I am, alive and able to think rationally (most of the time, at least) about the world and the people who call it home.
In this world, the median income is $850 US Dollars (USD). That means half the people on Earth make less than $850 each year. Half the people make more. I’m one of them. Money is not everything, and it’s not as important as people think, but having enough of it to buy food and a few toys is something to be thankful for.
People who have incomes of $40,000 USD are in the top three percent, globally. They are the richest people in the world. If the worldwide economy were evenly split up between Earth’s people, the average income would be $7,000 USD. Of course, all people ever seem to do is complain about money. Republicans are freaking out because they believe they are too heavily taxed. Democrats are losing their minds because their daily niche cause isn’t receiving the trillions of dollars of funding they think it should get. In every instance, it’s just a Three Percenter arguing with a three percenter. It’s the most privileged people on Earth bickering about cake, when they could be reading with their kids instead.
Next time Hadley asks to read to me, I think I will turn off the zombie show, which is really great, and give the gecko, or the dog, the night off. After all, I’m a person, and I’m lucky to be here.


