Geiger Counter

True grit   My daughter came outside early this morning to help me shovel the driveway before heading off to third grade. As we pushed and tossed the slab of fresh white snow to the side, I jiggled the shovel and assessed its considerable heft. “This snow is heavy,” I said. “This will make great snowballs.” “Dad!” Hadley exclaimed, looking around to see if anyone had heard me. “We’re not allowed to throw snowballs at school. It’s illegal.” “Really,” I said. “You can’t have snowball fights?” “No. Not just snowballs. We aren’t allowed to throw any snow at all.” How do they settle disputes? I wondered. How do the oppressed mete out winter justice? How do people learn who their friends and allies are if not in the trenches of a snowball war? How do they feel the rush that comes only from firmly packed ice stinging your face, blinding your eyes, then slowly, disquietingly trickling down the back of your neck, chilling you to your bones, then gradually growing warm and smelly, and weirdly itchy, as you sit in your classroom the rest of the day? I already knew she lived in a different world than the one I grew up in. I had vaguely pondered the differences: the cell phones, the terminology, the ubiquitous nature of information, simultaneously comfortable and disquieting. (Did you know that people are less likely to know things that can be easily Googled? In other words, the accessibility of knowledge ironically makes people dumber.) There was also the time, last year, when we went to a rodeo and Hadley informed me that they are not allowed to give each other horsey rides on the playground at school. “Dad, it’s illegal,” she scolded me. Don’t we all need to learn to carry one another, and to know our loved ones will carry us? I wondered. But something about the snowball law this morning really took the wind out of my sails. I have no idea if Hadley’s world is better or worse than the one I grew up in. To my eyes, people in this time are so much quicker to anger, so much faster to be wounded and hurt, so eager to judge and happy to systematically destroy their enemies’ lives rather than simply toss a few snowballs back and forth. But those are my eyes, formed by a different world, a world that is not this one. Who knows if they see things for what they really are?  Perhaps that is the key to parenting: Every generation raises children who come of age in a world totally alien to the one they came from. I know what it’s like to grow up in the 1980s. I know how to survive it. I know where the joys are hidden, like buried treasure on an old map. But I have no treasure map for the world today. It is one Hadley, who is eight years old, will have to fill in herself, only to grow up and learn, one day, that her own children will grow up in a world she does not understand. On and on it will go. It’s as if every generation moved to a totally new country, with different words, different rules, different ideas about truth and justice. It has probably always felt this way. Imagine spending your entire life learning how to make Clovis projectile points, only to see your children hunting with bronze. Imagine your bewilderment, and their exhaustion at your antiquated views. Our species’ greatest blindness is that we often equate that which is “new” with that which is “better.” But when something happens tells us nothing about its ethical impact on our lives. Likewise, the fact that something is old does not make it inherently good, either. In any case, I sent my daughter off to school in the morning, and I couldn’t help wondering how, as a law-abiding student, she will learn who her true friends are without fighting as a foot soldier in a great snowball battle. How she will know who will have her back. How she will know who will help her to her feet and dry her tears, dragging her to safety as the enemy pops over their snow wall and fires down on them. How will she learn that she, too, is the kind of person who will rush out into danger to help her friends? She can’t learn these things in organized sports, because in those games you are required to play, and your teams are picked for you by adults. No, these snowball fights on the playground taught us different things about ourselves and those with whom we battled and celebrated. It’s a common misconception for us to think that we are who we say we are. That we are the person we claim to be. That we are faithful or friendly or fierce. But in truth, we are often not what we say. We are what we do. We are faithful if we behave faithfully, and proclaiming it really has no bearing on the matter. We are compassionate, or brave, or tough, or caring, if we act that way. You are not what you say you are, and you are also not what other people say you are. You are what you do.  Ernest Hemingway famously defined courage as “grace under pressure.” He did not define it as calling oneself graceful in a moment of quiet and undaunting respite. So how, in the absence of snowball fights, I wondered yet again, will Hadley discover whether or not she has true grit? True Grit is a book and two movies, all of which are very similar. The best, I believe, is the 2010 movie by the Coen Brothers. The story is filled with robust characters and dark humor. My daughter’s favorite character is the protagonist, Mattie Ross, who says the following at the story’s outset:   “People do not give it credence that a young girl could leave home and go off in the wintertime to avenge her father’s blood. But it did happen. I was just fourteen years of age when a coward by the name of Tom Chaney shot my father down, and robbed him of his life, and his horse, and two California gold pieces that he carried in his trouser band.” “Chaney shot him. Chaney fled. He could have walked his horse, for not a soul in that city could be bothered to give chase,” she continues. “No doubt Chaney fancied himself scot-free. But he was wrong. You must pay for everything in this world, one way or another. There is nothing free except the grace of God.” Just prior to this, for just a brief moment, a single line from the Book of Proverbs flashes on the screen: “The wicked flee when none pursueth.” It’s a haunting thought, that when we do wrong, we are dogged by the bounty hunters of our own conscience. That even when we get away with something, we do not really get away with it, because wherever we go, we will be there, pursuing ourselves and pursued by ourselves, for all the things we have done and not done as we make our way through life. We chase ourselves from start to finish.  Mattie ends up chasing the man who shot her father with Rooster Cogburn, a drunken and ornery U.S. Marshal she hires, and LaBoeuf, a Texas Ranger who is pursuing the same fugitive but for a different crime. Both Rooster and LaBoeuf suggest that it does not matter what crime Chaney hangs for after they catch him. Mattie disagrees vehemently. She wants him to be punished for the crime of killing her father, not for one of his many other transgressions. Rooster and LaBoeuf, on the other hand, suggest that they catch him and turn him in another state, in Texas, where there is “a considerable reward,” which they would split. Mattie doesn’t care about the money. She wants him punished in Arkansas, the place where he gunned down her father. “I did not want him brought to Texas, to have Texas punishment administered for a Texas crime,” she says. “That was not our agreement.” “What you want is to have him caught and punished,” replies Rooster. “I want him to know he is being punished for killing my father!” she says. “You can let him know that. You can tell him to his face,” says Rooster. “You can spit on him and make him eat sand out of the road. I will hold him down. If you want, I will flay the flesh off the soles of his feet and find you an Indian pepper to rub into the wound. Isn’t that a hundred dollars’ value? “It is not,” says Mattie. “When I have bought and paid for something I will have my way. Why do you think I am paying you if not to have my way?” “It is time for you to learn you cannot have your way in every little particular,” replies Rooster. “Other people have their interests.” Mattie is good, but Rooster is correct. Rooster is prone to fits of cynicism. In one moment of despair, he describes himself as “a foolish old man who’s been drawn into a wild goose chase by a harpy in trousers (Mattie) and a nincompoop (LaBoeuf).” He is unsentimental, leaving two dead bodies without burying them and explaining, “The ground’s too hard. If they wanted a decent funeral, they should have got themselves killed in summer.” But while he is rough and crude, he clearly lives by a consistent moral code. It has been shaped by his lived experience. Mattie, on the other hand, is still a child, still in the process of forging her own moral code. Still drawing her own map. While Rooster has both his moral code and his toughness to sustain him, Mattie must get by primarily on her own grit, on her own tenacity, as she sees, hears and feels the world’s many joys and sorrows for the first time, and begins creating her own ideas of what it means to be good, and to live a good life. The word “grit” comes from the Old English grēot, meaning dust, earth, or gravel. It is the Earth itself, the thing we walk upon on our greatest adventures, the thing we stand on when our children are born, when we marry, when we love and lose those around us. It is the thing we lie down on when we die, and, when the ground thaws, it is the thing that will embrace us. According to the Book of Genesis, the first person was created when God breathed life into a handful of dirt from the ground. At the end of the story, Rooster has accompanied, and carried, Mattie as far as he can take her. “I am grown old,” he exclaims. It seems the world has passed him by, too. He dies, and she lives on. Then she grows old, too, in a world different from the one where she grew up. I don’t have a clue how to be a good parent. No one is as bewildered as me by this strange experiment. I will try not to begrudge my daughter the strange world in which she finds herself, and I will try to remember that she, too, will someday be perplexed by the place and time her sons or daughters are forged. I will, however, take my daughter to the past with me, from time to time. Like the great time travelers of old, I will take her to experiences and places the world is starting to forget. We have gone on many of these trips already. She has hunted and butchered deer. She has slaughtered chickens for dinner. She has fallen off a pony and clambered back on. She has looked something up in an old-fashioned dictionary. She has fished and wandered in the wilderness with no plan at all. She has ventured into these places and times. We have had, as they say in True Grit, “lively times.” And we will continue to go there, together, for as long as I am with her, until one day I am grown too old. Thankfully, that day has not yet come. For now, we will wage great snowball fights, together, and see what we are truly made of.