Letters to the Editor

Dear editor, Southwest Wisconsin residents are facing the huge high-voltage Cardinal-Hickory Creek transmission line with 17-story high towers that is cutting a wide swath through the scenic Driftless Area natural resources, family farms and rural communities. The Driftless Area Land Conservancy (DALC), Wisconsin Wildlife Federation (WWF) and our community partners are in court challenging ATC’s and ITC’s violations of key federal and state laws designed to protect the environment, but the transmission companies still continue to plow full steam ahead, bulldozing through our unique Driftless area landscape.   In his January, 2022, decision holding in favor of DALC/WWF, U.S. District Court Judge William Conley called out the transmission companies for creating “an orchestrated train wreck” by running up the costs and building right up to the edges of the Upper Mississippi River National Wildlife and Fish Refuge on both the Iowa and Wisconsin sides even though they are legally barred from crossing the protected Refuge. They are creating unnecessary environmental damage and wasting money that they are trying to charge to utility ratepayers. DALC continues to strongly oppose this destructive transmission line.  There are better, less expensive and less environmentally damaging ways to provide reliable, clean energy for Wisconsin and reduce pollution.   The federal court and state court recently heard oral arguments on two important cases.  The battle is not over.  Here’s what is happening in the courts. U.S. District Court Judge William Conley (Madison) issued a detailed, comprehensive opinion granting summary judgment mostly in favor of plaintiffs Driftless Area Land Conservancy, Wisconsin Wildlife Federation, National Wildlife Refuge Association and Defenders of Wildlife (Conservation Groups). Judge Conley held that the federal defendant agencies violated the National Environmental Policy Act by improperly skewing the environmental impact statement process to effectively predetermine their outcome preferring the proposed interstate high-voltage Cardinal-Hickory Creek transmission line. Judge Conley also concluded that the federal defendant agencies violated the National Wildlife Refuge System Improvement Act of 1997 by impermissibly allowing this huge transmission line to run through the protected Refuge even though it’s not compatible.   Judge Conley declared that this transmission line could not cross through the protected National Wildlife and Fish Refuge either by means of an easement or land exchange.  Nevertheless, the transmission line developers – ATC, ITC Midwest, and Dairyland Power Co-op – have continued building two separate costly line segments, one in Iowa and another in Wisconsin up to the edges of the Refuge even though they are legally barred from crossing through the protected National Wildlife Refuge.    The Defendant federal agencies (Rural Utilities Service, U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service and U.S. Army Corps of Engineers) and the three Defendant transmission companies appealed U.S. District Court Judge Conley’s decision to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit.  The four Plaintiff Conservation Groups filed a focused cross-appeal limited to the District Court’s failure to issue an injunction stopping construction of the transmission line pending resolution of the appeals. On September 28, 2022, a three-judge panel of the Court of Appeals heard oral arguments and questioned attorneys representing all of the parties.  The judges’ questioning of all attorneys was vigorous.   Howard Learner, Executive Director and Senior Attorney from the Environmental Law & Policy Center (ELPC) presented strong, sound positions on behalf of the four Conservation Groups to support our contention that Judge Conley’s substantive decision should be upheld and that an injunction should be put in place to stop further construction activities. The Court of Appeals is likely to issue its decision in late 2022 or early 2023. This case primarily focuses on issues arising from the Wisconsin Public Service Commission’s legally-flawed approval of the Certificate of Public Convenience and Necessity (CPCN) in September, 2019, which authorized the costly transmission line and destructive route to go forward. Our appeal had been delayed for almost three years.  Dane County Circuit Court Judge Jacob Frost heard oral argument on the merits of our appeal of the Commission’s decision approving the CPCN and the unlawful Wisconsin environmental review. ELPC Senior Attorney Brad Klein argued DALC’s and WWF’s case before Judge Frost, and attorneys for Dane County, Iowa County, the Village of Montfort, the Town of Wyoming and Save Our Unique Lands, in addition to community members Chris Klopp and Gloria Belken, joined us in presenting oral arguments and addressing the Judge’s questions. DALC and WWF contend that the state’s environmental review was legally invalid for much the same reasons as the U.S. District Court concluded that the federal environmental impact statement was legally flawed. Both the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) and the Wisconsin Environmental Policy Act (WEPA) require that all reasonable alternatives, including distributed renewable energy and storage, energy efficiency and demand response, and more efficient existing transmission line upgrades, must be fully and fairly analyzed and considered, which they were not. Our attorneys requested that the Circuit Court set aside the Commission’s legally flawed CPCN approval and WEPA environmental review. Judge Jacob Frost indicated he would rule “in the foreseeable future.”  Protecting our unique Driftless area landscape and communities, and the Upper Mississippi River National Wildlife and Fish Refuge, is hard work and takes long-term commitment. The Driftless Area Land Conservancy and our partners are in this fight for the long haul to win and make a difference for a better conservation and community future. Jennifer Filipiak Executive Director, Driftless Area Land Conservancy Dodgeville Dear editor, I wanted to share a few words with the River Valley community about our regional two-year UW campus. On November 22, UW System President Jay Rothman announced that UW-Platteville Richland will close its doors after the spring 2023 semester. Many would agree that a campus with 60 students cannot be sustained. If I were faced with these numbers, I would think the same way. But please permit me to tell the story of how we got here. Believe me, it did not have to be this way. Richland County has more than a 100-year tradition of higher education. Prior to UW-Richland opening in 1967, the Richland County Teachers College prepared educators for country schools for 60 years. Under the leadership of Marge Wallace and Senator Jess Miller, when the teacher’s college closed, UW-Richland opened. Richland County provided the land and the buildings. The state legislature and UW System provided the academic budget. And for the past 55 years, the campus has provided an affordable gateway to a public four-year degree. I am sure many citizens of Spring Green, Arena, Plain, and Lone Rock have been touched by UW-Richland.  Back in 2015, some seven years ago, UW-Richland, as it was known for many decades, was a vibrant campus with 500 students enrolled, including 50 international students from 20 different countries and territories. At the time, the Richland campus had a reserve fund exceeding $1 million. The Richland Country Campus Foundation had the second largest endowment in the UW Colleges, amounting to $13 million. Richland County, although on a tight budget, supported its local campus by maintaining the buildings and grounds. Diversified in its recruitment base and well-funded to serve its students and the community, the campus was on solid footing to weather the decreasing number of high-school graduates in the years ahead. So, what happened?  Then, Governor Scott Walker, preparing for a presidential bid, decided to give the UW System its own version of Act 10. Walker, a Tea Party extremist was aided in this work by newly elected state Senator Howard Marklein. A forensic accountant by trade, Marklein, ran campaign adds claiming that he and members of the “CPA caucus” had discovered a “slush fund” (read budget reserves, like any responsible business should have) at UW System. Marklein, himself a Tea Party extremist, was a strong proponent of the cuts as a member of the Joint Finance Committee. In the end, the Legislature, cut UW System permanently by $250 million. (One wonders today how Marklein can look himself in the mirror as he and his Republican colleagues sit on their own soon to be $6.6 billion “slush fund”?) The $250 million budget cut devastated UW-Richland. For UW Colleges, this amounted to a 20 percent cut in its operating budget. The loss of $6 million in operational funding from the state forced UW Colleges to regionalize its structure. This meant that administrative and educational resources of the Richland campus were cut to the bone. Students suffered. So did enrollment. The regional concept failed after two years. After that, the Richland campus was “farmed out” to UW-Platteville whose Chancellor Dennis Shields was wrestling with his own budget cuts and decreasing enrollments. In this scenario, UW-Richland became UW-Platteville Richland and lost its identity completely. Shields and his staff would not even permit UW-Richland to have its own recruiter. The Richland County Campus Foundation offered to pay for it. Chancellor Shields shot this idea down. UW-Platteville Richland became an afterthought at UW-Platteville. One wonders, too, what happened to former UW-Richland’s $1 million plus reserve fund?  Starved for resources and without its own campus identity after 55 years, the Richland campus, once a vibrant center of education and community, in 2015 has now become the target of the Board of Regents. Some Republican leaders and the UW System would have us believe that considerable efforts were made to support the campus and provide it with a future in the 21st century. They would argue that “we tried, and things just didn’t work out.” Nothing could be further from the truth. The aim here was to starve Richland and let it die. This was part of Tea Party Republicans’ concerted effort to undermine public institutions in general and even destroy public education. The Richland story is one of many that could be told statewide as counties, state agencies, and public workers struggle to meet the needs of taxpayers. As I write this, I am reminded of the wisdom and forbearance of former State Senator Dale Schultz. Senator Schultz was a great advocate for the Richland Campus. It is in him that state Republicans should seek inspiration and wisdom for the future.  I encourage citizens of the River Valley to reflect on their own experiences with UW-Richland. I’ve no doubt that many in our region have family stories about how UW-Richland or the Richland County Teachers College changed someone’s life. The question remains, are we satisfied with the fact that starting in fall 2023 no new stories will be told as the beautiful campus on Brush Creek with its brick buildings and coppertops sits empty?  Sincerely, Patrick Hagen,  Former CEO/Dean, UW-Richland (2010-2015) Spring Green Dear editor, A suggestion: as Christmas is so near, do you still need a gift for a loved one? My suggestion is easy to obtain and not very expensive. And mostly a wonderful gift that keeps on giving. Old Franklin Township Historical Society membership is my suggestion. I was not born or brought up here, but their newspaper is very insightful. Each newspaper is packed full of history of Plain I look forward to each fact filled page. Things that built the small village and surrounding areas.  I do Genealogy, and each article is backed up with footnotes citing their references. So Christmas, birthday, or any other gift needed...  This is the perfect answer for that person on your list. The person who wants to know a little more about this area of Wisconsin. Write to: Old Franklin Township Historical Society, 915 Wachter Avenue, Plain, WI 53577 or visit the society on Facebook. Sue Meise Spring Green Dear editor, Thank you to the Spring Green community for the support regarding our hot chocolate sale at North Park Pavilion right before the fireworks on the December 10th.  Because of everyone’s generous support, the Spring Green Scouts BSA Pack and Troop will be donating $200 to the Spring Green Food Pantry to help those in need!  We are very excited to be able to do this. Mike Wernsing Scoutmaster - Troop 38 Spring Green Dear editor, The holiday season is one of the most important times of year for families. People travel across Wisconsin to see their loved ones, but safety is sometimes lost in the hustle to holiday destinations. In Wisconsin, there were nearly 400 crashes that involved an impaired driver during the last holiday season. Seven people were killed. These tragedies are preventable because the choice is simple: if you’re drinking, don’t drive.  Someone is killed or injured in an impaired driving crash every two hours in Wisconsin. Last year, 166 deaths could have been prevented if a drunk driver had not gotten behind the wheel. Another 74 people in Wisconsin were killed in drug-related crashes in 2021 as Wisconsin, among other states, continues to see problems with drugged drivers. As the holiday season hits its stride, the Spring Green and Plain police departments, along with law enforcement agencies across the nation, are stepping up enforcement in an effort to eliminate impaired driving. The Drive Sober or Get Pulled Over campaign runs from December 16 through January 1, 2023. The enforcement and awareness efforts are not just about stopping, citing, or arresting drivers. This is about saving lives and preventing tragedies. Impaired driving is a challenge law enforcement cannot take on alone. We need everyone in Wisconsin to do their part. If you plan to celebrate this holiday season, identify a sober designated driver. If you’re feeling impaired, you likely are over the 0.08 BAC limit and, instead of risking an arrest or injuring others, you should take public transit, call a taxi, use a rideshare service, or ask a sober friend to drive you home. It’s just as important to speak up and discourage other people from taking that risk also, and if you see a driver you suspect is under the influence, call 911.  Remember, under Wisconsin’s “not a drop” law, drivers under age 21 are prohibited from having any detectable amount of alcohol in their system. All drivers are prohibited from having any detectable amount of illegal drugs in their system.  Our mission is to stop impaired driving all year long and we will continue those efforts every day that we are out patrolling Wisconsin’s roads. As always, because impaired driving is preventable, we are serious when we say, “Drive Sober or Get Pulled Over.” Thank you for your support to help keep our communities safe. Officer Alex Ziemke Spring Green Police Department