The Book Nook
Love stories plagued by secrets
Family secrets have played a role in many popular books, from “Jane Eyre” by Charlotte Brontë to “All The Light We Cannot See” by Anthony Doerr. For some, the discovery of a secret could cause embarrassment while for others it could mean the difference between life and death. Here are two historical novels where secrets play a crucial role in plots that contain drama, suspense and romance.
“The Chocolate Maker’s Wife” by Karen Brooks takes us back to England in the 18th century when a young woman’s life is radically changed after a new commodity called chocolate arrives on the scene. As the tale begins, Rosamund relates the family secret that explains why, in spite of her noble birth, she’s working as a servant at a rural inn.
She can manage the work and customers, but not an unnamed menace that forces her to be alert and wary every waking moment. Sometimes her intelligence help her sidestep the danger, but that’s not working today. While running from danger Rosamund narrowly escapes being trampled under the wheels of a rich man’s coach. Amazingly, he offers her an opportunity to trade her life of drudgery for the attractions of London.
She accepts his offer but soon it’s clear both are keeping secrets from the other. Rosamund realizes all is not well and as the mystery deepens, betrayal and other dangers threaten them both. Determining who she can trust becomes a problem, and a wave of disasters threaten more than just an end to her lavish new lifestyle.
I found this to be a well-written historical novel, although those seeking pure escapist fiction may dislike the sometimes inflated language or repetitive phrases. On the positive side, attention to detail and the book’s overall atmosphere made it easy to get a feel for the era. The 1660s was a time of political and religious turmoil in England and London was hit especially hard. The plague took a huge death toll and in the following year the Great Fire destroyed all but a small portion of the city. Also noted are journalism’s role in the Restoration Era and the tactics used to quell any criticism of the king.
Brooks keeps readers in suspense, filling in details at appropriate times. She thankfully avoids using one-dimensional characters, giving us a sympathetic protagonist and a solid, credible storyline. You may not believe Rosamund’s ability to charm everyone she meets, but many will appreciate her courage and intelligence. Those who like well-researched novels containing drama, romance and humor with a “Cinderella” feel will find a good read here.
In Natasha Lester’s “The Riviera House”, two women from different eras are linked by a family secret connected to stolen art.
Eliane had hoped to follow her passion for painting and continue studying art, but it’s 1939 and war is changing the Paris she grew up in and loves. She has to end her beloved life as an art student so she can help her family survive. The timing is terrible as she’s just met a fellow artist who fascinates her with his kindness and ability to see into her heart, which beats a little faster the closer they become. When France joins with England in declaring war against Germany she starts down a long, difficult road of fear and sacrifice darkened by heart-breaking loss.
Fast forward to 2015 where Remy has moved to a lovely place on the French Riviera. It’s very secluded, which suits her choice of cutting herself off from the world. One morning she notices an unknown man on her terrace, who disappears when he sees her watching him. She hopes he never returns, as she has no desire to interact with anyone. However, her only neighbors are determined to become acquainted and in meeting them she discovers the man from her terrace is part of their family. Despite her choice of self-isolation she’s drawn into their company, which is something she’s desperate to avoid.
As the novel alternates between past and present, details linking the two women will slowly be revealed. Remy wrestles with inner demons that drove her into isolation and self-recrimination. Eliane’s life is one of increasing danger as she takes one risk after another, knowing each could have severe repercussions. Both women face emotional battles that shake them to the core. Elements of bereavement, revenge and romance are featured, some in both stories.
Lester’s writing is absorbing and the dual timelines are handled well. Instead of toggling quickly between two tales, she devotes large sections to one timeline before switching to the other, allowing readers to become absorbed in each story. The plotting is well-done in both tales and particularly intense in Eliane’s portion. There’s effective use of twists and the romance aspect feels authentic.
Today the Louvre Museum in Paris is an iconic site open to all art lovers, but for three days in 1939 it was closed while employees worked frantically to keep as much of the collection as possible out of Nazi hands. Some of the characters in the 1939 portion of the novel are based on true characters, such as Rose Valland. She was an art historian who spied on the Germans, covertly recording as much as she could about stolen paintings and their destinations. Her heroic work resulted in the restoration of some pieces to their rightful place.
In the author’s notes Lester remarks on her awareness of dealing with sensitive subjects, which shaped her research, what to include and how to share that information.
Both novels have moving stories and likeable heroines who find ways to overcome loss, find love and embrace hope.


