The Book Nook

Expressive Blend of Poetry and Prose “Girl, Woman, Other” by Bernardine Evaristo is a lyrically written novel that lets us into the lives of twelve black British women.  Each seeks acceptance in a society that sees them as outsiders, regardless of whether they’re new to the country or life-long citizens. Each woman is given her own chapter, giving the initial impression that the book tells a dozen different stories.  It does, but as the narrative progresses readers will discover threads linking everyone together despite their class, cultural or sexual identity differences. The opening chapter features Amma, a 50-something writer anxious about how her latest play will be received.  Throughout her career, dreams of success were thwarted by those who considered her work too feminist, too lesbian or too radical for main-stream audiences.  Her plays have been relegated to tiny marginal stages and while she enjoys some name recognition, it’s limited to experimental theater lovers. Decades earlier Amma and her best friend Dominique cofounded a woman’s theater group with the motto “On our own terms or not at all”.  Their shared anti-establishment attitudes defined Amma’s plays, the latest which even she considers controversial and ground-breaking.  But tonight’s opening night is different from any other because it will occur in a very traditional venue – London’s National Theater.  She’s fearful the audience’s reaction will either bring “instant” success or brand her forever as a failure. Amma’s not the only one feeling pressure.  Others within her circle of friends and family wait to learn how the play will be received.  One of them is her daughter Yazz, who is the next to tell her story, adding a new voice and perspective.  As each new character gets her turn to speak we learn how their lives intersect, sometimes through overlapping narratives.  Some of the women are related by blood, others by circumstances or chance and each has a different story to share. These are tales of dealing with life’s challenges and run the emotional gamut.  Each story deals with feeling marginalized to various degrees.  One account shows an idealistic, hopeful woman at the start of a teaching career, tracking scars left by the daily grind and other difficulties over the years. The author ushers us not only into these women’s lives, but into their minds as well, providing a deeper understanding of their situations and the connections they share, some of them surprising.  She looks at degrees of separation between the characters while exploring serious subjects such as immigration, domestic abuse, sexuality and racism.  In spite of these sober topics, they’re handled with a pleasant lightness and energy and the nuanced aspect adds a contemporary dimension.  Infused with humor and poignancy, this unconventional novel manages to be both enlightening and entertaining. The writing style is noticeably different in several ways.  The plot seems non-linear until readers are far enough in to notice links between characters, after which time the pieces start falling into place.  From the first page it’s obvious this isn’t a structure that follows traditional punctuation rules.  Evaristo calls her style fusion fiction and successfully uses it to create a completely different feel from more conventional writing.  It seems tailor-made in this moving novel about class and race, moving fluidly in its presentation of complex characters. Another difference is that instead of making every aspect of each character easily recognizable, the author asks readers to adapt.  It reminded me of Amma’s not changing her plays to make them more palatable to the majority.  Finally, readers may find the self-righteous attitude of the first two characters off-putting, but those who continue reading will be rewarded with a humorous dimension that makes the cast relatable.  The characters’ collective experience provides a view into the female black British world with on-point, well-chosen language. Published in 2019, “Girl, Woman, Other” is her eighth novel and was nominated for numerous awards.  It resulted in the author sharing the 2019 Booker Prize with Margaret Atwood, becoming the first woman of color to achieve that prize.  This is just one of many awards she’s earned for writing and public service.  Evaristo has also received several honorary degrees. In 2020 she became the first woman of color whose work reached number one in the United Kingdom’s paperback fiction market.  Two of her works were adapted into British radio dramas.  She also organized and/or led several initiatives to advocate for artists and writers of color.  She is currently a professor of creative writing at Brunel University in London and the vice-chair of the Royal Society of Literature.